Home Page link  

Online Bill Paying vs "Quicken Bill Pay"

 

Quicken Personal Finance Discussions - Quicken - personal finance software discussions

 Post an article  get this group's latest topics as an RSS feed add this group's latest topics to your My MSN content add this group's latest topics to your My Yahoo content  add this group's latest topics to your Google content  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Online Bill Paying vs "Quicken Bill Pay" John Gregory 05-06-2006
Posted by John Pollard on May 9, 2006, 9:36 am
Please log in for more thread options
Lisa C wrote:
> Bleh.
> The Intuit site explains that QIF capabilities were left in
> place for
> use in technical service issues. It's still there because
> Intuit
> needs it.

> BUT it is disabled for all but cash accounts.

Wrong.

> Sure, you can
> import to a dummy account and move the transactions, but the
> categories are missing. And, there is even more possibility
> using the
> move that you will end up with duplicate transactions,
> regardless of
> the Intuit PR.

Sorry, but you *can* import directly into checking, savings, and
investment accounts in Q2005 and Q2006. You just haven't been
keeping up with this issue. (And QIF file importing was never
"disabled" for asset, liability, receivables, payables, and one
other that I've forgotten.)

--
John Pollard
First initial underscore Last name at mchsi dot com
Please reply to newsgroup



Posted by Lisa C on May 12, 2006, 10:14 am
Please log in for more thread options
> Lisa C wrote:
>> Bleh.
>> The Intuit site explains that QIF capabilities were left in place for
>> use in technical service issues. It's still there because Intuit
>> needs it.
>
>> BUT it is disabled for all but cash accounts.
>
> Wrong.
>
>> Sure, you can
>> import to a dummy account and move the transactions, but the
>> categories are missing. And, there is even more possibility using the
>> move that you will end up with duplicate transactions, regardless of
>> the Intuit PR.
>
> Sorry, but you *can* import directly into checking, savings, and
> investment accounts in Q2005 and Q2006. You just haven't been keeping up
> with this issue. (And QIF file importing was never "disabled" for asset,
> liability, receivables, payables, and one other that I've forgotten.)
>

The Intuit website directly refutes your statement. QIF importing for bank
accounts, credit cards and brokerage accounts was an included option in
Quicken for Windows PRIOR TO 2005. Beginning with 2005,
Intuit has disabled the QIF import for all but cash accounts.

From the Intuit website http://web.intuit.com/personal/quicken/qif/
"Beginning with Quicken 2005 for Windows, and for all future versions of
Quicken for Windows, QIF Data Import will no longer be available for most
accounts." Follow the link for more information and you find
"If you upgrade to Quicken 2006 for Windows you will no longer be able to
use QIF Data Import for your checking account (as well as savings, credit
card, 401(k), and all other brokerage accounts)."

If "you *can* import directly into checking, savings, and investment
accounts in Q2005 and Q2006" using QIF, please, post back in the ng with the
work-around.

I would appreciate it, and, given the number of posts regarding this issue I
am sure others would as well.



Posted by John Pollard on May 12, 2006, 11:09 am
Please log in for more thread options
Lisa C wrote:
>> Sorry, but you *can* import directly into checking, savings,
>> and
>> investment accounts in Q2005 and Q2006. You just haven't
>> been
>> keeping up with this issue. (And QIF file importing was
>> never
>> "disabled" for asset, liability, receivables, payables, and
>> one
>> other that I've forgotten.)
>
> The Intuit website directly refutes your statement. QIF
> importing for
> bank accounts, credit cards and brokerage accounts was an
> included
> option in Quicken for Windows PRIOR TO 2005. Beginning with
> 2005,
> Intuit has disabled the QIF import for all but cash accounts.
>
> From the Intuit website
> http://web.intuit.com/personal/quicken/qif/
> "Beginning with Quicken 2005 for Windows, and for all future
> versions
> of Quicken for Windows, QIF Data Import will no longer be
> available
> for most accounts." Follow the link for more information and
> you find
> "If you upgrade to Quicken 2006 for Windows you will no longer
> be
> able to use QIF Data Import for your checking account (as well
> as
> savings, credit card, 401(k), and all other brokerage
> accounts)."

I agree that what Intuit wrote does not agree with what I said.
By not only have I proven that Q2006 can import directly to
checking, savings, credit card, and investment accounts; I, and
others, have posted this several times - here in this newsgroup
and in the Quicken forums. (And Intuit themselves, first let on
this was possible in a response in the Quicken forums).

> If "you *can* import directly into checking, savings, and
> investment
> accounts in Q2005 and Q2006" using QIF, please, post back in
> the ng
> with the work-around.
>
> I would appreciate it, and, given the number of posts
> regarding this
> issue I am sure others would as well.

There are several variations on the theme, but if you look under
the hood, they are really all pretty much the same. Here is one
of many posts indicating how it's done.

http://makeashorterlink.com/?Q11A5191D

--
John Pollard
First initial underscore Last name at mchsi dot com
Please reply to newsgroup



Posted by John Pollard on May 12, 2006, 11:11 am
Please log in for more thread options
John Pollard wrote:

> By not only have I proven that Q2006 can import directly to

When he should have written:

"But not only have I proven that Q2006 can import directly to
...."

> checking, savings, credit card, and investment accounts; I,
> and
> others, have posted this several times - here in this
> newsgroup
> and in the Quicken forums.

--
John Pollard
First initial underscore Last name at mchsi dot com
Please reply to newsgroup



Posted by joe on May 8, 2006, 1:20 pm
Please log in for more thread options
On Mon, 8 May 2006 06:34:15 -0400, "Lisa C"

>> Your banks BillPay is a tarbaby. If you use it, you'll be able to
>> categorize your expenses but you won't be able to include checks written
>> on other banks or even your pocket cash. And you won't be able to switch
>> away from that bank's service because it will be hard to copy the
>> transactions into your new system. Although you can probably go through a
>> comma-separated values file step, but that's painful.
>>
>>
>????
>That is simply not true!
>
>Wachovia bank has offered free bill-pay through Quicken FOR YEARS. Before it
>was bought by Wachovia, my branch was a CoreStates, and then a FirstUnion.
>All offered bill-pay through Quicken (though at one time there was a charge
>of $3.99 per month if your balance went below a certain threshold, IIRC)
>
>As posted in this thread by Guy, you simply write a check -- either in the
>Online Center OR directly into the register, using the SEND term in the
>check number column. If you have not set up the payee as on online payee,
>Quicken will prompt you.
>
>You can even mix-and-match services. I use my bank's website to schedule
>fixed payments for loans, and Quicken to send variable payments like credit
>card and utilities.
>
>There is no distinction between transactions initiated at the bank website,
>checks written by hand, atm transactions, and those sent via the online
>center. When cleared through the bank, all transactions download for
>matching or accepting as new transactions.
>
>As for the free lunch, the OP is correct, it is not free. Banks, like other
>businesses, offer certain services to attract customers. Perhaps you will
>use a bank-associated credit card, or enter into a personal loan agreement
>with the ban, use the atm at a remote location, or order checks... all
>things banks can and do charge premiums on.
>
>Your free lunch is more likely to be threatened by the Intuit bean counters
>who discovered that their biggest cash-cow was not in improved software, but
>in disabling services for existing copies of older software. This includes
>such wonderful innovations as forcing upgrades by 'sunsetting' older
>software (disabling payroll, merchant services and other options in
>QuickBooks, and OFX online transfers in Quicken) and, in addition, removing
>some capabilities altogether (like the ability to import QIF files from your
>bank for checking, savings, and credit card accounts). Read some of the
>FAQ's for OFX download, and maybe you can pinpoint why Intuit does this.
>Q: Why does Intuit charge financial institutions a fee to connect to
>Quicken?
>A: Intuit charges a fee to financial institutions to connect to Quicken via
>Open Financial Exchange (OFX) because Intuit products, like Quicken, are
>uniquely positioned to provide financial institutions with a better way to
>attract, retain and serve their customers by offering a more valuable
>service. This small fee enables Intuit to offset costs, offer connectivity
>to more financial institutions, and continue to develop better products and
>services using the faster, easier and more accurate OFX method.
>
>Q: Does Intuit charge all financial institutions the same fee to connect
>Quicken?
>A: Intuit offers various pricing options for connectivity based on the size
>of institutions customer base. Smaller banks pay less than larger banks.
>
>Q: Will my Financial Institution charge fees for OFX download?
>A: Financial Institutions determine what - if any - fees will be charged for
>download into Quicken via OFX. Contact your Financial Institution and ask
>them if they charge fees for download into Quicken. When you call, be sure
>to explain that you want to download into Quicken and would like to
>understand if there are any costs for doing so.
>
>Q: Does Intuit require banks to charge their customers for connectivity?
>A: Absolutely not. Intuit does not mandate that financial institutions
>charge their customers for OFX connectivity with Quicken. In fact, many
>financial institutions offer this service free of charge to their customers.
>
>Of course, the folks at Intuit were not quite so forthcoming in telling the
>customers who just this year were forced to upgrade from the 2003 product.
>We found out AFTER conversion. The choice is to take the newer product, with
>QIF disabled, or send for a refund, and keep your older product with
>INTUIT-disabled OFX.
>


Perceptive and well said Lisa!
Count on nothing from I.

regards,
joe

Similar ThreadsPosted
Re: Online Bill Paying vs "Quicken Bill Pay" May 12, 2006, 4:50 pm
Re: OFX - Online Banking & Bill Paying June 12, 2006, 11:17 am
Best online bill paying service ? July 6, 2006, 11:01 pm
OFX - Online Banking & Bill Paying June 3, 2006, 10:37 am
Online Bill Paying - Tranactiion Reconciliation July 3, 2006, 11:43 pm
How Do I Get the Program to Start on the Bill Paying Page? March 20, 2007, 6:31 pm
online bill pay: Quicken vs. Citibank? May 11, 2006, 6:53 pm
Online Bill pay MS-Money conert need help June 22, 2007, 2:46 am
Pay bill via Quicken August 12, 2006, 8:48 am
Quicken Bill Pay December 1, 2006, 9:59 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy
This site is not affiliated with Intuit - makers of Quickbooks and Quicken software
This site is not affiliated with Sage Software - makers of Peachtree accounting software
XML SitemapXML Sitemap